Overview of the SAMPL6 pKa challenge: evaluating small molecule microscopic and macroscopic pKa predictions

Mehtap Işık, Ariën S Rustenburg, Andrea Rizzi, Marilyn R Gunner, David L Mobley, John D Chodera
Journal of Computer-Aided Molecular Design 35:131, 2021
[DOI] [bioRxiv] [GitHub] [manuscript and figure sources]

The SAMPL6 pKa challenge assessed the ability of the computational chemistry community to predict macroscopic and microscopic pKas for a set of druglike molecules resembling kinase inhibitors. This paper reports on the overall performance and lessons learned, including the surprising finding that many tools predict reasonably accurate macroscopic pKas corresponding to the wrong microscopic protonation sites.

Standard state free energies, not pKas, are ideal for describing small molecule protonation and tautomeric states

M R Gunner, Taichi Murakami, Ariën S. Rustenburg, Mehtap Işık, and John D. Chodera.
Journal of Computer Aided Molecular Design 34:561, 2020. [DOI] [PDF] [GitHub]

Here, we demonstrate how the physical nature of protonation and tautomeric state effects means that the standard state free energies of each microscopic protonation/tautomeric state at a single pH is sufficient to describe the complete pH-dependent microscopic and macroscopic populations. We introduce a new kind of diagram that uses this concept to illustrate a variety of pH-dependent phenomena, and show how it can be used to identify common issues with protonation state prediction algorithms. As a result, we recommend future blind prediction challenges utilize microstate free energies at a single reference pH as the minimal sufficient information for assessing prediction accuracy and utility.

pKa measurements for the SAMPL6 prediction challenge for a set of kinase inhibitor-like fragments

Mehtap Işık, Dorothy Levorse, Ariën S. Rustenburg, Ikenna E. Ndukwe, Heather Wang , Xiao Wang , Mikhail Reibarkh , Gary E. Martin , Alexey A. Makarov , David L. Mobley, Timothy Rhodes*, John D. Chodera*.
* co-corresponding authors
Journal of Computer-Aided Molecular Design special issue on SAMPL6 32:1117, 2018.
[DOI] [PDF] [bioRxiv] [Supplementary Tables and Figures] [Supplementary Data (includes Sirius T3 reports on all measurements)]

The SAMPL5 blind challenge exercises identified neglect of protonation state effects as a major accuracy-limiting factor in physical modeling of biomolecular interactions. In this study, we report the experimental measurements behind a SAMPL6 blind challenges in which we assess the ability of community codes to predict small molecule pKas for small molecule resembling fragments of selective kinase inhibitors.

Acquired resistance to IDH inhibition through trans or cis dimer-interface mutations

Andrew M. Intlekofer,  Alan H. Shih,  Bo Wang,  Abbas Nazir,  Ariën S. Rustenburg,  Steven K. Albanese, Minal Patel, Christopher Famulare, Fabian M. Correa, Naofumi Takemoto, Vidushi Durani, Hui Liu, Justin Taylor, Noushin Farnoud, Elli Papaemmanuil, Justin R. Cross, Martin S. Tallman, Maria E. Arcila, Mikhail Roshal, Gregory A. Petsko, Bin Wu, Sung Choe, Zenon D. Konteatis, Scott A. Biller, John D. Chodera, Craig B. Thompson, Ross L. Levine, and Eytan M. Stein
Nature 559:125, 2018. [DOI] [PDF]

We probe the biochemical and biophysical mechanisms underlying an unusual set of clinical resistance mutations that appeared in trans in the IDH2 dimer interface in cancer patients treated with IDH2 inhibitors.

Bayesian analysis of isothermal titration calorimetry for binding thermodynamics

Trung Hai Nguyen, Arien S. Rustenburg, Stefan G. Krimmer, Hexi Zhang, John D. Clark, Paul A. Novick, Kim Branson, Vijay S. Pande, John D Chodera, David D. L. Minh.
PLoS One 13:e0203224, 2018. [DOI] [bioRxiv] [GitHub]

We show how Bayesian inference can produce greatly improved estimates of statistical uncertainty from isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) experiments, allowing the joint distribution of thermodynamic parameter uncertainties to be inferred.

Binding Modes of Ligands Using Enhanced Sampling (BLUES): Rapid Decorrelation of Ligand Binding Modes Using Nonequilibrium Candidate Monte Carlo

Samuel Gill, Nathan M. Lim, Patrick Grinaway, Ariën S. Rustenburg, Josh Fass, Gregory Ross, John D. Chodera, and David Mobley.
Journal of Physical Chemistry B 22:5579, 2018. [DOI] [ChemRxiv] [GitHub]

Nonequilibrium candidate Monte Carlo can be used to accelerate the sampling of ligand binding modes by orders of magnitude over instantaneous Monte Carlo.

L-2-Hydroxyglutarate production arises from noncanonical enzyme function at acidic pH

Intlekofer A, Wang B, Liu H, Shah H, Carmona-Fontaine C, Rustenburg AS, Salah S, Gunner MR, Chodera JD, Cross JR, and Thompson CB.
Nature Chemical Biology 13:494, 2017. [DOI] [PDF] [GitHub]

At low pH, metabolic enzymes lactate dehydrogenase and malate dehydrogenase undergo shifts in substrate utilization that have high relevance to cancer metabolism due to surprisingly simple protonation state effects.

Measuring experimental cyclohexane-water distribution coefficients for the SAMPL5 challenge

Ariën S. Rustenburg, Justin Dancer, Baiwei Lin, Jianweng A. Feng, Daniel F. Ortwine, David L. Mobley, and John D. Chodera.
Journal of Computer-Aided Molecular Design 30:945, 2016. [DOI] [bioRxiv] [PDF] // data: [GitHub]
Solicited manuscript for special issue of the Journal of Computer Aided Molecular Design on the SAMPL5 Challenge.

The SAMPL Challenges have driven predictive physical modeling for ligand:protein binding forward by focusing the community on a series of blind challenges that evaluate performance on blind datasets, focus attention on current challenges for physical modeling techniques, and provide high-quality experimental datasets to the community after the challenge is over. For many years, challenges focused around hydration free energies have proven to be extremely useful, with theory now able to determine when experiment is wrong. To replace these challenges, since no more hydration free energy data is being measured, we proposed to use the partition or distribution coefficients of small druglike molecules between aqueous and apolar phases. We report the collection of cyclohexane-water partition data for a set of compounds used to drive the SAMPL5 distribution coefficient challenge, providing the experimental data, methodology, and insight for future iterations of this challenge.